PolicyBrief
H.RES. 414
119th CongressMay 15th 2025
Recognizing that the United States has a moral and legal obligation to provide reparations for the crime of enslavement of Africans and its lasting harm on the lives of millions of Black people in the United States.
IN COMMITTEE

This resolution asserts the Federal Government's moral and legal obligation to provide comprehensive reparations, including financial compensation, to descendants of enslaved Black people for centuries of systemic harm.

Summer Lee
D

Summer Lee

Representative

PA-12

LEGISLATION

Resolution Demands $16 Trillion in Reparations, Formal Apology, and 13th Amendment Change

This Congressional resolution is a formal statement asserting that the U.S. Federal Government has a moral and legal obligation to provide comprehensive reparations to descendants of enslaved Black people. It lays out a case detailing centuries of systemic harm—from chattel slavery to Jim Crow and ongoing discrimination—and calls for a massive, multi-faceted plan for redress. The resolution specifically estimates that the financial reparations needed to close the racial wealth gap amount to a minimum of $16,000,000,000,000 (16 trillion dollars), which would be an unprecedented fiscal commitment.

The $16 Trillion Question: Closing the Wealth Gap

For most people, $16 trillion is an abstract number, but the resolution ties it directly to the economic reality of the racial wealth gap. This is the difference in net worth between Black and White families, a gap the resolution argues is a direct legacy of denying Black Americans access to wealth-building opportunities like the Homestead Act, Social Security, and the G.I. Bill. If this resolution were to translate into law, the fiscal implications would be enormous, fundamentally reshaping the federal budget and requiring significant new revenue streams, which would directly affect every U.S. taxpayer.

Accountability and Constitutional Shifts

Beyond the financial demand, the resolution requires several significant non-monetary changes. First, it demands a formal apology from the government for state-sanctioned slavery and subsequent anti-Black practices. Second, it calls for a major constitutional change: amending the 13th Amendment to repeal the clause that allows slavery or involuntary servitude as punishment for a crime. This clause is often cited as the legal basis for forced labor and low wages in the modern prison system, so changing it would fundamentally alter the landscape of criminal justice and incarceration.

Property Disputes and Real-World Restitution

One of the most complex proposed actions is the call for the restoration or adequate compensation for property unjustly taken through mechanisms like racially restrictive covenants or eminent domain. Think about a family whose land was taken generations ago under questionable circumstances. This provision opens the door for potential legal claims and disputes over current property ownership, requiring the government to establish clear—though currently undefined—criteria for what constitutes "unjustly taken" property and how to value it decades later. This could create significant uncertainty for homeowners and businesses currently occupying land that might be subject to a claim.

Education, Health, and Cultural Repair

Finally, the resolution demands systemic changes aimed at long-term repair. This includes requiring public school curricula to critically examine the history of slavery and Jim Crow, and providing free education for students attending Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) who commit to serving Black communities. It also mandates institutionalizing culturally appropriate mental health services and strengthening community hospitals. These provisions aim to address disparities in education and health that the resolution attributes directly to the historical denial of resources and opportunities, attempting to repair the damage far beyond a simple cash payment.