PolicyBrief
H.RES. 410
119th CongressMay 14th 2025
Expressing the sense of the House of Representatives that President Trump must comply with the Foreign Emoluments Clause, by submitting all plans for his jumbo jet gift from Qatar immediately to Congress.
IN COMMITTEE

This resolution expresses the House's view that President Trump must immediately submit plans to Congress for accepting a jumbo jet gift from Qatar to comply with the Foreign Emoluments Clause.

Jamie Raskin
D

Jamie Raskin

Representative

MD-8

LEGISLATION

House Demands Trump Submit $400M Qatari 'Flying Palace' Plans to Congress Immediately

This resolution is a direct shot across the bow from the House of Representatives, stating its opinion that the President must follow the Constitution’s rulebook—specifically the Foreign Emoluments Clause—before accepting massive gifts from foreign governments. The immediate trigger? Reports that President Trump intends to accept a Boeing 747-8 aircraft, described as a “flying palace” and valued at over $400 million, from the royal family of Qatar.

The Constitution’s No-Free-Lunch Rule

Article I, Section 9, Clause 8 of the Constitution is pretty clear: No President can accept any gift, emolument, office, or title from a foreign state without explicit approval from Congress. This isn’t a new rule; it’s a foundational check designed to ensure the President’s loyalty remains solely with the American people, not with a foreign power that might be trying to buy influence. The resolution points out that historically, presidents—from Andrew Jackson to Abraham Lincoln—have faithfully deposited foreign gifts with the government when Congress didn’t give the green light. The House is essentially saying the President needs to stop, step back, and get permission before taking possession of this jet.

The $400 Million Question: Who Pays for the ‘Free’ Plane?

The resolution highlights a major practical concern: this plane isn't actually 'free.' While the Qatari royal family is reportedly gifting the aircraft, the text notes that accepting it would not replace the existing contract for updating Air Force One. Instead, the U.S. taxpayer would likely be on the hook for hundreds of millions or even billions more to retrofit and secure the aircraft to meet Presidential security standards. Think of it like getting a free, high-end sports car but then realizing you have to spend a fortune on specialized armor plating, classified communications systems, and a dedicated, highly trained crew just to drive it to work. For the average person, this means a potentially massive, hidden cost buried in the defense budget, contradicting any claim that this gift would save money.

National Security and the Fine Print

Beyond the cost, the resolution raises a critical national security issue. Accepting a massive asset from a foreign state, especially an autocratic one like Qatar, introduces significant risks. The text specifically mentions the concern over surveillance risks. When a foreign entity provides a high-value, complex piece of equipment like a jumbo jet, the potential for embedded surveillance technology or vulnerabilities is a serious worry. The House is demanding that the President immediately submit all plans for accepting this gift to Congress, ensuring that national security experts and oversight committees can vet the deal before the President takes possession, preventing a potential compromise of national security and classified information.