PolicyBrief
H.R. 87
119th CongressJan 3rd 2025
Protecting Our Children from the CDC Act
IN COMMITTEE

The "Protecting Our Children from the CDC Act" mandates the public posting of all clinical trial data regarding the safety and effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines before they can be added to the child and adolescent immunization schedule. It also removes any existing COVID-19 vaccines from the schedule until the required data is released.

Andy Biggs
R

Andy Biggs

Representative

AZ-5

LEGISLATION

COVID-19 Vaccine Data Must Be Public Before Added to Child Immunization Schedule, Says New Bill

This bill, straight-up called the "Protecting Our Children from the CDC Act," changes the rules for adding COVID-19 vaccines to the recommended immunization schedule for kids and teens. Instead of just the CDC's Advisory Committee making the call, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) now has to post all the clinical trial data about the vaccine's safety and effectiveness publicly on the CDC website before it can be added to the list.

Data Dive Before the Jab

The core idea here is transparency. Before any COVID-19 vaccine gets added to that childhood immunization schedule – you know, the one your pediatrician uses – all the data from clinical trials has to be out in the open. We're talking de-identified data, of course, so no personal health info gets splashed around (as per SEC. 2). Think of it like this, if you are a mechanic you get to see all the parts and how they perform before installing it. If you are a programmer, you get to see the code and test results before implementing it in your system. This bill means that all the data is available for review, not just summaries or conclusions. This could be a big deal for parents who want to do a deep dive into the research before making a decision about vaccinating their kids.

The Current Schedule on Pause

Here's where things get interesting. The bill removes any COVID-19 vaccine currently on the child and adolescent immunization schedule. They can only go back on after that data dump happens and all other legal requirements are met (SEC. 2). This could be a hiccup for families who rely on that schedule for their kids' vaccinations. Imagine showing up for your child's regular checkup and finding out a previously recommended vaccine is temporarily off the list. That's the potential real-world impact.

The Good, The Bad, and The Unknown

On one hand, more transparency is generally a good thing. It could build trust and allow for more informed decisions. On the other hand, raw clinical data can be complex. Will most people, even those with older children in college, be able to make sense of it without expert guidance? Will this lead to misinterpretations and more vaccine hesitancy? Also, requiring the data to be posted before adding a vaccine to the schedule could create delays. If the posting process gets bogged down, kids might miss out on important vaccinations. The bill aims to make the process more open, but it might also make it more complicated, with potentially significant effects on families and public health.