PolicyBrief
H.R. 749
119th CongressJan 28th 2025
Stop Illegal Reentry Act
IN COMMITTEE

The "Stop Illegal Reentry Act" increases the penalties for individuals who illegally reenter the United States after having been removed, especially repeat offenders and those with criminal histories. It introduces mandatory minimum sentences for aggravated felons and repeat re-entrants.

Stephanie Bice
R

Stephanie Bice

Representative

OK-5

LEGISLATION

Stop Illegal Reentry Act: Mandatory 5-Year Sentences for Some Undocumented Immigrants

The "Stop Illegal Reentry Act" is all about toughening up the penalties for people who come back into the U.S. illegally after being deported or removed. This isn't just a slap on the wrist – we're talking increased prison time and mandatory minimum sentences, especially for those with prior criminal records.

Cracking Down

This bill lays out a tiered system of punishment. If you're caught re-entering the U.S. illegally after being removed, you're looking at a fine, up to 5 years in prison, or both (SEC. 2). But, if you have three or more misdemeanors (drug-related, crimes against a person) or a prior felony before being removed, that jumps up to a fine, up to 10 years in prison, or both. For those previously convicted of an aggravated felony or with two prior convictions for illegal reentry, it's a mandatory minimum of 5 years, maxing out at 20 years, plus fines (SEC. 2). "Aggravated felony" is a term used in immigration law to describe a range of serious crimes, from murder and trafficking to, in some cases, theft or filing a false tax return if the sentence was at least one year. The mandatory minimum is a big deal – it means judges can't go any lower than 5 years, no matter the circumstances.

Real-World Ripple Effects

Let's say a construction worker, originally from Mexico, was deported five years ago after a DUI. He comes back to the U.S. illegally to rejoin his family, including his U.S. citizen children. Under this new law, because of that single prior misdemeanor, he could face up to 10 years in prison. Or consider a small business owner who overstayed her visa, was deported, and then returned illegally. If she had a prior aggravated felony, even something like a non-violent drug offense from a decade ago, she's now facing a mandatory 5 to 20 years behind bars. These are the kinds of situations this bill creates.

Bigger Picture and Potential Problems

This bill fits into a broader pattern of stricter immigration enforcement. While the stated intent is to deter illegal reentry, it could have some significant knock-on effects. The mandatory minimum sentences, in particular, raise concerns. They tie judges' hands, preventing them from considering individual circumstances. This might sound tough on crime, but it could also lead to disproportionately harsh outcomes. We could see more people locked up for longer, which means more strain on the prison system and more families separated. Plus, this could make people even more afraid to interact with law enforcement, even if they're victims of a crime or eligible for some form of legal relief.