PolicyBrief
H.R. 5891
119th CongressOct 31st 2025
Withhold Member Pay During Shutdowns Act
IN COMMITTEE

This bill mandates the reduction or escrow of Congressional Member pay for days when a government shutdown is in effect.

Bryan Steil
R

Bryan Steil

Representative

WI-1

LEGISLATION

No Pay for Shutdowns: Bill Imposes Direct Financial Penalty on Congress Starting 2026

The Withhold Member Pay During Shutdowns Act is as straightforward as its title suggests: it stops the paychecks of Members of Congress for every day the federal government is shut down. This isn't about cutting their future salary; it’s about making sure that when the government’s funding lapses, the people responsible for keeping it running feel the financial squeeze immediately.

The 'No Pay, No Play' Rule

This bill defines a “Government shutdown” simply as any period when appropriations lapse for one or more federal agencies or departments (Sec. 2). If Congress fails to pass a budget or continuing resolution and the government runs out of money, the financial clock starts ticking for lawmakers. The bill mandates that for every 24-hour period the shutdown is active, one day's worth of pay is deducted from a Member’s compensation. For someone earning the standard Congressional salary, that’s a direct hit to the bank account for every day they fail to do their primary job: funding the government.

The Escrow Loophole: How They're Handling the Constitution

Here’s where it gets slightly bureaucratic, but it’s crucial for understanding the timeline. The Constitution’s 27th Amendment prevents Congress from passing laws that change their own pay until after the next election. To navigate this, the bill sets up two different systems based on the date.

For any government shutdown that happens before the November 2026 general election, the bill uses an escrow account (Sec. 2). Instead of outright losing the money, the payroll administrator (the Secretary of the Senate or the Chief Administrative Officer of the House) must withhold the daily pay and deposit it into a special account. The money sits there until the pay reduction effective date (post-November 2026), at which point all the escrowed funds are released back to the Members. This temporary setup is a legal maneuver to impose a penalty now without technically violating the 27th Amendment, which prohibits Congress from increasing or decreasing their pay during their current term.

For shutdowns that happen after the November 2026 general election, the gloves come off. At that point, the pay is simply reduced directly. No escrow, no refunds—the money is withheld permanently for the duration of the shutdown. This is the bill’s ultimate goal: creating a direct and immediate financial consequence for legislative failure.

Real-World Stakes: The Pressure Cooker

For regular folks, a shutdown means delayed tax refunds, closed national parks, and federal services grinding to a halt. For Members of Congress, this bill adds a personal financial incentive to avoid those political messes. This is a direct accountability measure. If you’re a busy professional juggling mortgages and childcare, you probably want your representatives to be focused on keeping the government running, not negotiating over their own salary while essential services are suspended.

However, this also creates an enormous pressure cooker. While the goal is to force compromise, the risk is that the financial penalty could incentivize rushed, poorly considered funding bills just to avoid losing a paycheck, rather than encouraging thoughtful, long-term legislative solutions. The bill is clear, though: if the funding lapses, the pay stops. It’s a clean line between performance and compensation, making the cost of political gridlock very personal for the 535 people in the House and Senate.