PolicyBrief
H.R. 1711
119th CongressFeb 27th 2025
DHS Intelligence and Analysis Oversight and Transparency Act
IN COMMITTEE

Mandates annual audits and congressional oversight of the Department of Homeland Security's intelligence data collection and usage.

Laurel Lee
R

Laurel Lee

Representative

FL-15

LEGISLATION

DHS Intelligence Arm Faces New Annual Audits Under 'Oversight and Transparency Act'

The "DHS Intelligence and Analysis Oversight and Transparency Act" mandates yearly check-ups on the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) intelligence operations, specifically how they handle massive data sets. This means the DHS's Office of Intelligence and Analysis will be under the microscope, with annual audits diving into their information systems and bulk data – think huge piles of info collected without specific targeting.

Data Deep Dive: What's Getting Audited?

The bill focuses on "bulk data," which is essentially large quantities of data scooped up without any filters. The Under Secretary for Intelligence and Analysis is in charge of these audits, and they're supposed to follow established intelligence oversight rules. The bill also requires the Office of Intelligence and Analysis to notify congressional committees within 30 days whenever they start analyzing or using a new bulk data set, including the terms and conditions. Any changes to those terms? Another 30-day notification window kicks in. Plus, Congress gets a report within 30 days after each audit, laying out all the findings.

Real-World Radar: How This Could Play Out

Imagine DHS collects location data from a widely-used app to track potential threats. Under this bill, they'd have to disclose how they're using that data, what rules they've set, and who has access. If they decide to share that data with another agency, they have to notify Congress about the change in terms. This is all about keeping tabs on how intelligence agencies use the vast amounts of information they collect.

Checks and Balances: The Four-Year Review

To make sure these audits are actually effective, the Comptroller General (basically, the government's top watchdog) will review the whole process within four years. They'll look at how the audits are being implemented and offer recommendations for improvement to the relevant congressional committees. This adds another layer of accountability to ensure the DHS intelligence office is playing by the rules. The concern here is that a lot of this 'bulk data' may not be valuable, or worse, might infringe on privacy of regular citizens. This bill aims to put some safeguards in place.

Connecting the Dots: Existing Laws and Future Implications

This bill builds on the Homeland Security Act of 2002, adding specific oversight requirements for intelligence activities. While it aims for transparency, the effectiveness will hinge on how strictly these audits are conducted and how seriously Congress takes the findings. The definition of "bulk data" is fairly broad, leaving room for interpretation – and potential overreach. The four-year review is crucial to catch any loopholes or unintended consequences that might pop up as this new oversight system gets rolling. Section 2 of the bill is where all the action is, laying out the audit requirements, reporting deadlines, and the Comptroller General's review.